New York City, a city of dreams and contrasts, has inspired countless artists and musicians to capture its essence in song. Among them is Sharon Van Etten, whose track 'Seventeen' from her album 'Remind Me Tomorrow' offers a unique perspective on the ever-evolving nature of this iconic city.
In this article, we delve into the layers of 'Seventeen', exploring how Van Etten's personal journey and the city's transformation intertwine to create a powerful narrative.
The City as a Character
New York City has long been a muse for musicians, with its vibrant energy and diverse neighborhoods providing an endless source of inspiration. From Frank Sinatra's 'New York, New York' to Jay-Z's ode to the city, these songs capture the essence of a place that is both a concrete jungle and a romantic ideal.
What makes Van Etten's contribution unique is her focus on the city's evolution and the personal growth that occurs within its boundaries. She captures the sentiment expressed by Joan Didion, who described New York as a place that is 'infinitely romantic' yet accessible only to the very young.
A Song of Personal Growth and Urban Change
'Seventeen' is more than just a song about a city; it's a reflection on the passage of time and the changes it brings. Van Etten, an adopted New Yorker, shares her perspective on the city's transformation, from the bright-eyed optimism of youth to the realization that change is not always positive.
The song's lyrics, 'I used to be free / I used to be 17', evoke a sense of nostalgia for a time when the world seemed limitless. As Van Etten sings, 'Downtown harks back / Halfway up the street', we're reminded of the city's ability to both inspire and constrain.
Visualizing the City's Impact
The music video for 'Seventeen', directed by Maureen Towey, takes us on a journey through Van Etten's New York. From Union Pool to the Marcy Street subway stop, these locations are more than just settings; they're symbols of the artist's growth and the city's influence.
Towey's vision captures the city's dual nature: tender and tough, nurturing and destructive. It's a powerful representation of the complex relationship between an artist and their environment.
A Song of Acceptance and Perspective
While 'Seventeen' is mournful, it's not a song of regret. It's a celebration of life's ephemerality and the understanding that change is inevitable. This sentiment echoes Bob Dylan's wisdom in 'To Ramona': 'Everything passes, everything changes.'
Van Etten's song reminds us that with change comes growth and that our perspectives evolve as we navigate life's journey. It's a powerful message, especially when paired with Joni Mitchell's lyrics from 'Both Sides Now': 'Something's lost, but something's gained, in living every day.'
Conclusion
'Seventeen' is a testament to the power of music to capture the human experience within the context of a city. Van Etten's song invites us to reflect on our own journeys, the places that have shaped us, and the ever-changing nature of life. It's a beautiful reminder that, like New York City, we too are works in progress, constantly evolving and adapting to the world around us.
